Trading System Simulation Errors

Trading System Simulation Errors

chaz
2010-05-05 12:54:07

I have analyzed results of the Trading System (TS)I created & spotted an errors in reported trades results;
It inflates te Profits by Adjusting OpenPrice of the security bought at Open and increases the close price at which a simulated trade/position was closed.

Environment I tested:
Portfolio selected consists of 9 ETFs (BGZ, BGU, FAS, FAZ, ERY, ERX, USO, OIL, RSX)
Period used 1/4/2010-5/5/2010

Ex. of numbers reported in simulated trade
ERY Position - 3400 shares opened on 4/5/2010
Adj. Open Price $8.00 (why $8.0 ? Opening price on that day was 9.08)
Curr. Price $9.33 (close price on 4/5/2010 - correct)
Position gets selected to close by rules in TS
On 5/5/2010 I get position closed with following values:
Adj. Open Price $8.00
Close Price $10.0 (ERY price never reached that level & Daily High in Quotes DB was only $9.93 for 5/5/2010, close $9.66, Open $9.72, Low $9.47))

That trade was added to report with Preturn $6800 which is not right as stock never traded on those 2 days between $8-10 that system used.

Are these simulator calculation going to be fixed soon or is there any other reson for those errors I encountered?

I can provde my TS rules & formuas I used Strategy, Ranking Optimize & MM as well as setings.

Thx in advance for any comment or suggestions to fix it.
Chaz

QuantShare
2010-05-05 14:05:34

Best Answer

Hi,

This is not a bug; you probably set the tick size field to 2.

The tick size or the minimum amount a security can increase or decrease is used in futures trading and it can be set globally or per-symbol.

Globally, it can be changed by updating a trading system then selecting (Settings -> Settings).
Per-Symbol, it can be changed by selecting a symbol then clicking on Symbol -> Update.

chaz
2010-05-18 08:53:30

Thank you QS for the fix. I had global Tick size = 1.0 . in Trading System Settings. Modifying it to 0.01 fixed the problem. Chaz

QuantShare
2010-05-18 13:53:53

You're Welcome. You can also update the tick size per-symbol.

Get more messages

No more messages

Back


Trading Items Vary the Start Date of a Trading System Simulation Benchmark Return in a Trading System Simulation MAE and MFE of a Trading System R Squared of a Trading System Equity Curve Optimizable Fibonacci Long and Short Trading System	How-to Lessons How to add a metric in the trading system simulation report How to debug a trading system using the money management tool How to add custom position-based metrics to your trading system How to optimize the number of positions in a trading system How to set order type of a trading system programmatically
Related Forum Threads Comp Function in Trading System Rules Simulator Trading System Report Trading System time period not including start day Combined Trading System report causes hang How to edit a trading system i've downloaded from shared server?	Blog Posts True portfolio simulation applied to trading systems How to build and backtest a robust stock trading system Inverse Fisher Transform: Indicator, composite and trading system Trading System Analysis: Backtesting report and custom measures 9 mistakes you should avoid when backtesting an end-of-day stock ...