In-Sample return for Walk Forward Analysis?

In-Sample return for Walk Forward Analysis?

Back to threads - Tags: walk-forward ,optimization

Praveen Baratam
2016-08-31 15:47:08

How is the Cumulative In-Sample return for Walk Forward Analysis calculated?

Example WFA Report - http://goo.gl/J8CEdy

In the above report the "In-Sample Annual Return" for all the periods is greater than 35% but the cumulative annual return used for the calculation of Walk Forward Efficiency is 13.7%

How is this possible? How is the Cumulative In-Sample Annual Return (Depicted in Red in the above link) calculated?

Am I missing something?

QuantShare
2016-09-01 11:03:42

The cumulative in-sample return is calculated by taking the sum of profits/loss for every in-sample then annualizing the result using the sum of the trading days in all in-samples as period.
Please send support an example that can help us reproduce this so that we can analyze it and explain what is going on.

Kiran
2019-05-08 20:44:06

This seems to be a bug with the Cumulative Annual Return. I'm using contiguous, non-overlapping out-of-sample periods (from 4/1/2014 - 5/1/2019), and the Average Annual return per oos period is 28%, but the Cumulative annual return is 9% - Cumulative return should be close to 28% (despite some divergence due to laws of compounding).

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1kwvIFQ0siX9DI6pFF1TvBXUenB0tjHsD/view?usp=sharing

QuantShare
2019-05-09 09:57:23

This can happen. If you have a year with 90% return and another one with -45% return then the average annual return would be 22.5% while the cumulative return is 4.5%.

Get more messages

No more messages

Back


Trading Items Market cap, ROE, ROA and Forward PE for U.S. Stocks - Fundamental... Ignore Orders for Recently Purshased Securities based on Return 10-bar moving average return for S&P 500 stocks Annual Return of a Security Extensive Fundamental Data for U.S. Stocks	How-to Lessons How to get fundamental data for U.S. Stocks How to screen for stocks having a high correlation with the Dow J... How to get stocks for a particular index using the global script How to download EOD quotes for active and valid stocks only How to add future bars to plan for market scenarios
Related Forum Threads Custom Fitness Functions for Walk Forward Testing Equity Curve and Trades list for out-of-sample Walk Forward test In-Sample and Out-Of-Sample Dates for Optimization Walk Forward Testing Walk forward info	Blog Posts How to Display the Year-to-Date Excess Return in a Pivot Table Select the best ETFs combination to maximize your return and redu... How to Select the Best Market Indicator for your Trading System How to Scan for Parallel Resistance and Support Lines How to Backtest Your Trading System for Each Industry